Media Influencer

helping people break out of pigeonholes since 2003

Quote to remember

TAGS: None

There shouldn’t be writers and fans. We’re all writers on such platforms and should be all equal. The moment there are writers and ‘names,’ it’s a failure of the system.
- Ashok Banker on why he stopped using social media.

Note: The writer-fan distinction should not collapse into some false and, god forbid, forced equalisation. It should collapse into us being fans as well as having fans. That is the strength of the network.

Terry Pratchett reading guide

TAGS: None

I am a big fan of Terry Pratchett. I often say that the best book on political philosophy I have ever read is his Night Watch. But as Cory Doctorow points out:

…how daunting it must be to be confronted with Pratchett’s 33 Discworld novels and try to figure out where to start. Part of the charm of these books is that they’re not written in any main sequence, but rather in several interrelated series that follow the lives of many different characters and subplots.

and provides a handy reading guide.

I usually recommend people begin with Interesting Times, or Guards! Guards! or Men at Arms. The main thing is to start. :)

How to build strawmen

TAGS: None

Nick Carr’s in his post about the book Everything is Miscellaneous picks on a particular thing on page 9 (and stops reading there).

For decades we’ve been buying albums. We thought it was for artistic
reasons, but it was really because the economics of the physical world
required it: Bundling songs into long-playing albums lowered the
production, marketing, and distribution costs because there were fewer
records to make, ship, shelve, categorize, alphabetize, and inventory.
As soon as music went digital, we learned that the natural unit of
music is the track. Thus was iTunes born, a miscellaneous pile of 3.5
million songs from a thousand record labels. Anyone can offer music
there without first having to get the permission of a record executive.

Carr baulks at Weinberger’s calling track the natural unit of music and proceeds to ruminate on the history of music formats – large pieces a la Beethoven, music albums that can transcend the ‘meaning’ of individual songs, etc., etc.. All vaguely interesting and possibly true. Alas, not relevant to the point David Weinberger is making. As a listener – and also a potential creator and distributor – I can now unbundle someone else’s albums (i.e. packaging of tracks) to create my own combinations. Calling something a unit does not suggest it is complete and finite, it merely makes it a discrete piece to be used as a building block to bigger, better or more meaningful things. In identifying the track as a unit, David Weinberger highlights the possibility of creating new ‘albums’ rather than reducing music experience to tracks or singles.

And yet it is the wholesale unbundling of LPs into a "miscellaneous
pile" of compressed digital song files that Weinberger would have us
welcome as some kind of deliverance from decades of apparent servitude
to the long-playing album. One doesn’t have to be an apologist for
record executives – who in recent years have done a great job in
proving their cynicism and stupidity – to recognize that Weinberger is
warping history in an attempt to prove an ideological point.

And what’s wrong with an ideological point? After all, we do live in interesting times, which even professional contrarians such as Nick Carr cannot ignore. We all have things that we appreciate and treasure – whether it be LPs or music albums, rustling of the Sunday paper, favourite ads and brands. It would be very odd indeed to say that things we are accustomed to are not worth our attention. Nostalgia for things past is not objectionable, forcing it on others as the best or only option is.

Will the new stress on discrete digital tracks bring a new flowering of
creativity in music? I don’t know. Maybe we’ll get a pile of gems, or
maybe we’ll get a pile of crap. Probably we’ll get a mix. But I do know
that the development of the physical long-playing album, together with
the physical single, was a development that we should all be grateful
for. We probably shouldn’t rush out to dance on the album’s grave.

We are getting a new flowering of creativity in music thanks to the internet, as well as in writing, video and spoken word. And yes, we do get both – a pile of gems and a pile of crap. So Nick Carr’s question is either an empty rhetoric or ignorance of the online world. As for the LP album or a single, nobody’s taking that away from him. There are some artists who are releasing new music on vinyl LPs for nostalgia’s sake. But there are millions of others that are no longer constrained by the tyranny of music industry (and of other industries that easily come to mind).  The choice of an album as well as your own mash -up is what it’s about. But to Mr Carr, a mash-up may be something that only cooks and amateurs do.

There are bigger fish to fry though then music albums. It is called …the liberation mythology of the internet according to Mr Carr.

This mythology is founded on
a sweeping historical revisionism that conjures up an imaginary
predigital world – a world of profound physical and economic
constraints – from which the web is now liberating us. We were
enslaved, and now we are saved. In a bizarrely fanciful twist, the
digital world is presented as a "natural" counterpoint to the supposed
artificiality of the physical world.

Historical revisionism? I don’t think so. I can see the difference between the digital and physical worlds in parallel existence right now. In music distribution The Long Tail is one of the most obvious example of the digital world not facing the constraints of the physical world.

Often the ‘liberation’ that occurs in the online world is so palpable that the constraints of the physical world becomes intolerable at times. This is disturbing many a business model and bringing some industries to their knees – the shifting balance of power towards people formerly known as consumers or audience. And as to the natural aspect of the online world? In as much human interactions and communication is naturally distributed and decentralised, or peer-to-peer in other words, the online environment has helped us come the full circle from the buzzing of the bazaars to the chatter of bloggers. Communication is natural, it is a survival trait and only in industrialised artifice of the media industry something like that can be called a skill. The internet has ‘liberated’ many a writer, podcaster and film-makers. In other words it has ‘liberated’ individual expression by giving it tools to produce, share and distribute. And it doesn’t take a history degree to know that this is a step forward.

Weinberger, Anderson and others trying to articulate and describe such changes will inevitably become lightening rods for those who feel threatened or do not understand what is happening around them. They attack those who put this to words, which is fair enough. Words can be imperfect reflection of reality, especially when the changes are fundamental and across many dimensions. That however, doesn’t make what they attempt to describe any less true.

After all it’s not about the demise of long player but the dawn of play-as-you-like-it.


TAGS: None

Last Tuesday I went to a book launch party at a club in Pall Mall, which despite the surroundings turned out to be not so traditional an affair. The book was Mediocracy by Fabian Tassano, who observes that:

…some areas of culture are dumbing down, while others are increasingly incomprehensible. Both things are symptoms of mediocracy, a new model of society in which content is sacrificed in favour of appearance and ideological correctness.

I bought a copy of the book, which was bagged by Brian Micklethwait, who promised to blog about it first. It seems I beat him to it. I did manage to leaf through the book and found it wonderfully satirical, erudite and refreshing. It should be a companion to anybody who abhors today’s practice of using language to disguise, hollow out and spin reality. Or as Dr Madsen Pirie of Adam Smith Institute puts it:

Tassano expertly skewers politically correct pomposity and looks beyond the bland surface to the rough reality beneath.

Once Brian returns the book, I shall write more, with my favourite quotes from it. For now, pictures will have to do.


Quote to remember

TAGS: None

For a first-time author, Marco said, having people read parts of her book online and decide not to buy it isn’t the worst thing that could happen. The more disturbing scenario is for no one to read it at all. "The idea of obscurity being an author’s worst enemy is absolutely true."

- Wired article on Google Print Library Project.

  • Author: Adriana
  • Published: Oct 7th, 2005
  • Category: Books
  • Comments: 2

Communities Dominate Brands – relevant as ever

TAGS: None

Communities Dominate Brands could be mistaken for a book which is just about the shape of things to come. And whilst it does indeed have a lot to say about the future, the really interesting thing about this book is that it is about the reality of brands and markets right now in 2005.

The fact much of what Tomi and Alan have to say is controversial and counter-intuitive to branding strategists and marketing insiders is just a measure of the seismic nature of the changes being wrought by the ‘Connected Revolution’. The world is not just changing, it has already changed and many of the axioms and practices which underpin how entire industries operate are now little more than a form of ‘phantom limb syndrome’.

This book is not just an essay about understanding how the convergence of many technologies has changed everything, it is nothing less than a survival guide which I would urge people in businesses of all sizes to read from cover to cover if they want prosper in a world in which the balance of power on so many levels has shifted in favour of the digitally empowered individual and the affinity groups they form. These communities really do dominate brands. Get used to it.

cross-posted from tBBC blog

© 2009 Media Influencer. All Rights Reserved.

This blog is powered by Wordpress and Magatheme by Bryan Helmig.